Answering the Five Most Common Objections Through First-Century Context & Language
The same books that show him forgiving sins and receiving worship also show him tired, praying, and saying the Father is greater than I. Those sentences are not a later attack added from outside. They are in the story. They need an answer that stays inside the story.
1. Why Honest Readers Ask Hard Questions
Once a first-time reader—especially someone from a Jewish or skeptical background—sees how consistently the Gospels connect Jesus to Yahweh’s actions and titles in the Old Testament, a natural set of follow-up questions arises. In the very same Gospels where Jesus calms seas, forgives sins, and accepts worship, He also prays to God, says "the Father is greater than I," and gets tired or hungry.
To a modern reader unfamiliar with the New Testament’s framework, those two sets of verses can look like a contradiction. However, to the first-century Jewish authors who wrote the Gospels, both truths fit together seamlessly: Jesus is the eternal Divine Son who genuinely took on full human flesh (John 1:14; Philippians 2:6–8). Because He is both fully God and truly human, He speaks and acts from both realities.
2. The Five Most Common Objections—Answered Directly
Objection 1: "Why did Jesus say, 'The Father is greater than I' (John 14:28)?"
In John 14:28, right before His crucifixion, Jesus tells His disciples: "If you loved Me, you would have rejoiced, because I am going to the Father, for the Father is greater than I." Critics often quote this single sentence to argue that Jesus cannot share the divine nature of God.
- Position vs. Nature (Greater vs. Better): Notice that Jesus uses the word "greater" (Greek: meizon—referring to rank, station, or position), not "better" (Greek: kreitton—referring to superior nature or essence). For example, the President of a country holds a greater office than a citizen, even though both share the exact same human nature.
- The Context of John 14:28: At that moment, the Father was seated in heavenly glory, while Jesus was standing on earth in humble human flesh, about to be beaten and crucified. Jesus was telling His grieving disciples to be happy for Him because He was leaving His lowly earthly station to return to the Father’s glorious throne—the very glory He shared with the Father "before the world existed" (John 17:5).
- Read Alongside John 10:30: In the very same Gospel, Jesus states: "
I and the Father are one
" (John 10:30)—affirming oneness of divine nature while distinguishing their roles during His earthly mission.
Objection 2: "Why did Jesus pray to God if He shares God’s identity?"
Skeptical readers frequently ask: "If Jesus is God, was He praying to Himself in the Garden of Gethsemane?" The answer is no—because the New Testament never teaches that Jesus is the Father.
- Distinction of Persons Within One God: From the opening verse of John’s Gospel—"
In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God"
(John 1:1)—the New Testament teaches an eternal, loving relationship between the Father and the Son within the one true God. When Jesus prayed, the Son was speaking in real fellowship with the Father, not talking to Himself. - Living as Our True Human Representative: Having taken on real human flesh (Hebrews 2:17), Jesus lived a life of complete trust, obedience, and prayer to the Father—showing humanity what perfect relationship with God looks like.
Objection 3: "Why did Jesus say, 'Why do you call Me good? No one is good except God alone' (Mark 10:18)?"
When a rich young ruler kneels before Jesus and asks, "Good Teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?" Jesus replies: "Why do you call Me good? No one is good except God alone" (Mark 10:18). At first glance, this can sound like Jesus is denying He is God.
- A Socratic Question Designed to Wake the Man Up: In first-century Judaism, rabbis refused to be called "Good Teacher" because absolute goodness belonged to Yahweh alone. Notice that Jesus never says, "I am not good" or "I am not God." Instead, He asks a piercing question to force the young man to think through his own words: "Do you realize what you are saying when you call Me 'Good'? Only God is truly good—so are you ready to treat Me as God?"
- Confirmed Three Verses Later (Mark 10:21): Immediately afterward, Jesus tells the man to sell everything and "follow Me"—placing loyalty to Jesus above every earthly treasure, a demand only Yahweh had the right to make.
Objection 4: "Why did Jesus say only the Father knows the day and hour of the end (Mark 13:32)?"
In Mark 13:32, speaking of the final day of judgment, Jesus says: "But concerning that day or that hour, no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father."
- Voluntary Self-Limitation in Human Flesh (Philippians 2:7): When the eternal Son entered human history as a real human child, Luke notes that Jesus "increased in wisdom and in stature" (Luke 2:52). As part of genuinely sharing human life, Jesus voluntarily chose not to access certain divine prerogatives—such as the Father’s secret calendar for the end of the age—during His earthly mission.
- Notice the Ascending Ladder of Rank in Mark 13:32: Look closely at the hierarchy in Jesus’s sentence: humans -> angels -> the Son -> the Father. Even while stating He does not know the hour, Jesus places Himself above all human prophets and above all angels in heaven.
Objection 5: "Why didn’t Jesus ever walk around saying the exact English words, 'I am God, worship Me'?"
This is among the most common objections. The answer lies entirely in the first-century Jewish world in which Jesus lived, and in what the Bible itself says:
- 1. First-Century Jews Associated 'God' (Ho Theos) With the Father: In first-century Jewish speech, saying "I am God" without qualification would have sounded to a crowd like Jesus was claiming to be God the Father Himself—which would have been false, since Jesus is the Son.
- 2. Old Testament Actions Spoke Louder Than Labels: As this entire series has shown, first-century Jewish writers and listeners communicated identity through sacred Old Testament actions and titles. When Jesus forgave sins by His own word, commanded the storm, claimed to be the Good Shepherd of Ezekiel 34, applied "I Am" (Ego Eimi) to Himself, and swore under oath that He would sit at God’s right hand and ride the clouds of heaven (Daniel 7:13), every Jewish listener understood Him loud and clear.
- 3. Their Reaction Proves They Understood Him: Nobody picks up stones to execute a man for saying "I am a prophet" or "I am a good teacher." Yet in John 8:58–59 and John 10:30–33, the religious leaders immediately picked up stones to execute Jesus, explicitly stating why: "because You, being a man, make Yourself God"—and the High Priest condemned Him to death for blasphemy for the exact same reason (Mark 14:62–64).
3. Side-by-Side Summary: Two Truths, One Person
4. Closing Reflection for the First-Time Reader
When you step back and look at the whole picture—from Jesus’s birth as "Immanuel" (God with us), through His boyhood in the Temple, His baptism, His miracles over nature and sin, His Transfiguration, His courtroom confession before the High Priest, His crucifixion, His resurrection, and the immediate worship of His Jewish eyewitnesses—the New Testament tells one unified, unmistakable story.
The first-century Jewish authors of the Gospels did not ask their readers to abandon the One True God of Abraham, Moses, and the prophets. Instead, they showed that the One True God of Israel had kept His ancient promise to come personally to rescue His people—standing in human flesh in the person of Jesus of Nazareth.