How a Dying Man Called Jesus Innocent and a King
1. Who This Person Was
He was born about 5 BC, a guess from a grown man, and he died on the same day Jesus did, around 33 AD. Luke never gives his name. Later centuries did, and those names are not in the Gospel. His whole meeting with Jesus was the cross. Matthew and Mark say both men on those crosses mocked him. Luke tells one who did not. This study follows Luke's man.
Luke does not give his name. He was one of two criminals crucified with Jesus (Luke 23:32-33, 39-43). Later centuries named the two men. Those names are not in the Gospel. This study stays with what Luke wrote.
Matthew 27:44 and Mark 15:32 say those who were crucified with him also reviled him. Luke tells a criminal who rebuked the other and asked to be remembered. The reports are not the same sentence. This study follows Luke’s man, and it does not pretend Matthew and Mark said the same thing.
2. The Scriptures Behind the Meeting
A guilty man under a Roman cross spoke about justice, innocence, and a kingdom.
- Isaiah 53:9 —
The servant had done no violence, and there was no deceit in his mouth
. The criminal said this man had done nothing wrong. - A king’s reign — He asked to be remembered when Jesus came into his kingdom. He treated the crucifixion as the way into a reign, not the end of one.
- Paradise — Jesus answered with today, and with paradise. The kingdom he asked for was answered as presence with Jesus that same day.
3. What Happened
Luke’s scene is a few sentences.
- 1. The mockery (Luke 23:39). One of the criminals railed at him. Are you not the Christ? Save yourself and us.
- 2. The rebuke (Luke 23:40-42). The other answered,
Do you not fear God, since you are under the same sentence?
And we indeed justly, for we are receiving the due reward of our deeds. But this man has done nothing wrong. Then he said, Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom. - 3. The answer (Luke 23:43). Jesus said, Truly, I say to you, today you will be with me in paradise.
- Two men died beside him, and they did not answer him the same way. One said that if he were the Christ he should save himself and them. The other feared God, said they were punished justly, and that this man had done nothing wrong. Isaiah had said the servant had done no violence and there was no deceit in his mouth. That criminal asked to be remembered when Jesus came into his kingdom. He treated the cross as the way into a reign, not the end of one. Jesus answered him, not the mocker: today you will be with me in paradise. The lesson of that hour is an innocent king who takes a guilty man with him the same day. God come down does not climb off the wood to prove himself. He saves the one who asks while they are both still dying.
4. Side-by-Side Comparison
5. A Word from the Greek
A. "Nothing wrong" (Greek: ouden atopon)
Atopon is what is out of place, improper, a crime. The criminal clears Jesus of the charge while accepting his own.
B. "Kingdom" and "paradise" (Greek: basileia; paradeisos)
He says kingdom. Jesus says paradise, and today. The dying man’s request is answered as a place with Jesus, not as a rescue off the cross.
6. What the Gospels Do Not Add
There is no later life to tell. He died that day. Luke does not name him. What the meeting shows is a condemned man confessing his own guilt, Jesus’ innocence, and a kingdom still ahead, and Jesus receiving him.
What they were already pointing to
The men on the crosses beside him were already pointing, and they did not point the same way. One thought the Christ should save himself and them. The other thought Jesus had done nothing wrong and was a king whose kingdom was still ahead, and he asked to be remembered in it. The soldiers and the crowd had their own words. The Son, the Christ, the one who saves, and the Lord are true. The logic of these stories builds to his identity: he is God. That is the center. Luke keeps the man who was already saying the king, and Jesus answered him that same day.
One criminal thought that if Jesus were the Christ he should save himself and them. The other thought Jesus had done nothing wrong, and that he was a king whose kingdom was still ahead. He asked to be remembered when Jesus came into that kingdom. He did not ask to be taken off the cross.
Matthew and Mark say the men crucified with him also reviled him. Luke tells one who did not, and he puts the confession in a guilty mouth. The author chooses a scene the others do not tell, and he lets Jesus answer with today and with paradise. Who the two men thought Jesus was is the whole of the scene. Luke keeps the one who thought he was an innocent king.
7. Summary
One man on the next cross mocked. The other said they were punished justly and that Jesus had done nothing wrong, and he asked to be remembered in Jesus’ kingdom. Jesus said that today he would be with him in paradise. The meeting is short. It shows an innocent king, and a kingdom that includes a guilty man on that same day.