How a Man Who Had Kept the Commandments Went Away Rather Than Follow
1. Who This Person Was
He was born about 10 AD. Matthew calls him young, so he was younger than the fishermen, and the year is only a guess from that word, on the day he ran up to Jesus around 33 AD. He was alive in Jesus' years. Mark says he was rich. Luke says he was a ruler. None of them gives his name. He asked what he must do to inherit eternal life, and he went away sad. They never tell his death, and they never bring him back.
Mark says he was a man who ran up and knelt, and that he had great possessions (Mark 10:17, 22). Matthew says he was young (Matthew 19:20, 22). Luke says he was a ruler (Luke 18:18). He asked what he must do to inherit eternal life. He did not become a disciple. The meeting shows the call, and the refusal.
2. The Scriptures Behind the Meeting
He came with the commandments, and with the word good. Jesus pressed both.
- Exodus 20 — The commandments he was told to recite are the ones he said he had kept from his youth.
- Deuteronomy 6:5 —
Love the Lord with all you have
. The one thing he lacked was a wealth he would not release. - Psalm 49:6-7 —
Those who trust in wealth cannot ransom a life
. He wanted eternal life and kept the fortune.
3. What Happened
Mark’s telling includes the look of love. Matthew and Luke tell the same refusal.
- 1. Good teacher (Mark 10:17-18). He asked,
Good Teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?
Jesus said,Why do you call me good?
No one is good except God alone. Matthew’s form is, What good deed must I do? and Jesus says there is only one who is good. - 2. The commandments, and the one thing (Mark 10:19-21). Jesus listed the commandments about murder, adultery, theft, false witness, and honoring father and mother. The man said he had kept them from his youth. Jesus, looking at him, loved him, and said, You lack one thing. Go, sell what you have, give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven, and come, follow me.
- 3. He left (Mark 10:22). Disheartened by the saying, he went away sorrowful, for he had great possessions. Jesus then said how hard it is for those who have wealth to enter the kingdom of God.
- He ran up, knelt, and asked the good teacher what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus would not leave the word good alone. Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone. Then he recited the commandments the man said he had kept, looked at him, loved him, and told him the one thing he still lacked: sell, give to the poor, and follow me. The man went away sad. He kept the fortune. Mark does not bring him back. The lesson of that road is the call itself. Eternal life was not another deed added to a list. It was following the one who stood there, the one beside whom goodness belongs to God alone. His sorrow is the conclusion. He would not take the relation Jesus offered.
4. Side-by-Side Comparison
5. A Word from the Greek
A. "Why do you call me good?" (Greek: ti me legeis agathon)
Jesus does not say, I am not good. He asks why the man uses the word, and he says no one is good except God alone. Then he calls the man to leave his wealth and follow him. The sentence puts goodness with God and the call with himself. It is not a denial, and it is not a slogan that finishes the question by itself.
B. "Follow me" (Greek: deuro akolouthei moi)
The same call he gave fishermen. The man’s sorrow is the answer. He wanted the life and would not take the call.
6. What the Gospels Do Not Add
The Gospels do not say he came back. There is no later conversion to add. He is a witness by refusal. Jesus loved him, told him the one thing he lacked, and watched him leave because he had much.
What they were already pointing to
He was already pointing at a good teacher who could name the deed that inherits eternal life. Jesus asked why he used the word good, and said no one is good except God alone. Then he loved him and told him to sell, give, and follow. The man went away sad. Those who heard it were left with that leaving. The Son, the Christ, the one who saves, and the Lord are true. The logic of these stories builds to his identity: he is God. That is the center. This meeting keeps goodness with God alone, and it sets follow me beside the teacher the man wanted. He walked away from that call.
He thought Jesus was a good teacher who could tell him what to do to inherit eternal life. He said he had kept the commandments. Jesus asked why he used the word good, and said no one is good except God alone. Then he loved him and told him to sell, give, and follow. The man went away sad. He kept the thought he came with. He would not take the call.
Mark tells the look of love and the sorrowful leaving, and he does not bring the man back. Matthew and Luke tell the same refusal. The authors end on the walk away, so the reader is left with what the man thought Jesus was, a good teacher with advice, and with what Jesus set beside that thought: God alone is good, and follow me.
7. Summary
A rich man ran up, knelt, and asked the good teacher what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus sent the word good back to God alone, heard that the man had kept the commandments, loved him, and told him to sell, give to the poor, and follow. He went away sad. The meeting is short, and it is a no. It shows a call to follow set beside the God who alone is good, and a man who wanted the life without the call.