Named errors that often hide inside objections to the biblical Jesus—a living list

How to use this list

This list invites careful readers—including Muslim readers—to test objections with the same critical tools used in logic and historiography. It does not treat later non-Bible writings as parallel authority. It does not equate later renamed figures with the Jesus of Scripture. Invitation to think is not soft-sell of a false christ.

Each entry gives the standard name from informal logic / critical thinking, the common objection shape, why it is an error, and the clearer question.

1. Argument from Silence

Also called: argumentum ex silentio; often paired with Moving the Goalposts

How it often shows up: If Jesus were God, he would have said the exact sentence I require (I am God in my preferred wording). He did not say that sentence; therefore he is not God.

Why it fails: Absence of your preferred formula is not absence of the claim. Jesus used the titles, acts, and worship patterns of Israel’s God (I AM, Son of Man, forgiving sins, receiving worship, one with the Father). Demanding a modern slogan, then ignoring the evidence he did give, is silence-as-proof plus a moving target.

Clear thinking: Ask what counts as a claim of deity in first-century Jewish Scripture language—then weigh John 8:58; 10:30–33; 20:28; Mark 2:5–12; 14:61–64; Philippians 2:6–11—not whether he used your later sentence.

2. Moving the Goalposts

Also called: raising the bar; special demand for evidence

How it often shows up: Show me a verse. (You show John 1; John 20:28; Thomas; Paul.) That doesn’t count; show me something else. Or: that is interpretation; show me plainer words.

Why it fails: When evidence is answered by endlessly changing what would count, the standard is not truth-seeking. It is unfalsifiable resistance.

Clear thinking: Freeze the standard first: What evidence would settle this? Then test Scripture by that standard without moving it after each answer.

3. Straw Man

Also called: strawman; misrepresentation

How it often shows up: Christians believe three gods / God took a wife and had a son / the Father died on the cross.

Why it fails: Historic Christian confession is one God; Father, Son, and Spirit; eternal Son, not a biological romance; the Son suffered in his humanity. Attacking a cartoon is easier than facing the Bible’s claim.

Clear thinking: Steel-man the actual claim first. Then object to that—not to a rewritten enemy.

4. Equivocation

Also called: ambiguity fallacy; shifting definitions mid-argument

How it often shows up: Person means human individual, so three Persons means three gods. Or: Son means physical offspring, so Son of God is blasphemous biology.

Why it fails: The argument uses one word in two senses. Biblical and creedal Person / Son are not smuggling pagan mythology. Changing the meaning mid-stream invents a contradiction.

Clear thinking: Define terms as the text and the historic confession use them before declaring a contradiction.

5. False Identity / Illicit Name-Matching

Also called: oversimplification; false equivalence of referents; category error of identity

How it often shows up: Your Jesus and our later renamed figure are the same person because some stories overlap (virgin birth, miracles, honor as a messenger).

Why it fails: Shared surface details do not make the same referent. A later portrait that denies the cross, denies deity, and rewrites the story is a different christ. Name-matching is the critical-thinking mistake of oversimplifying identity.

Clear thinking: Compare claims, not labels. If the claims contradict (Lord and God vs prophet-only; crucified and risen vs not crucified), they are not the same person.

6. False Dichotomy

Also called: false dilemma; either/or fallacy; black-and-white thinking

How it often shows up: Either God is one, or Jesus is God. Either he prays, or he is God. Either he dies, or he is God.

Why it fails: Scripture’s claim is not two gods. It is the one God revealed as Father, Son, and Spirit; the Son incarnate who prays as man and is worshiped as Lord; who truly dies in the flesh and rises. The dilemma smuggles in a definition that already forbids the incarnation.

Clear thinking: Ask whether a third option exists that the Bible actually teaches—before forcing an either/or.

7. Begging the Question

Also called: petitio principii; circular assumption

How it often shows up: God cannot be crucified; therefore Jesus was not crucified / is not God. Or: our later book is true; therefore the Gospel records are false wherever they disagree.

Why it fails: The conclusion is already packed into the premise. History and Scripture are not allowed to speak; the assumption decides first.

Clear thinking: Separate the question: What did happen? What does the text claim? Then ask what that implies about God—do not use the implication to erase the evidence.

8. Argument from Incredulity

Also called: appeal to personal incredulity

How it often shows up: It is unthinkable that God would allow a prophet (or his Son) to be shamefully killed; therefore it did not happen.

Why it fails: Shock is not a historical method. The apostles preached a crucified Messiah precisely because it was scandalous—and still true (1 Corinthians 1:18–25).

Clear thinking: Test by witnesses, Scripture, and early proclamation—not by what feels fitting to a later theology.

9. Cherry-Picking

Also called: card-stacking; selective evidence; confirmation bias in argument form

How it often shows up: Accept Bible lines that fit a prophet-only Jesus; reject or declare corrupt the lines that call him Lord and God, show the cross, or show worship.

Why it fails: Selecting only friendly data is not weighing evidence. It is protecting a conclusion.

Clear thinking: Take the whole witness of a book (e.g., John; Mark; Paul) before declaring what Jesus is.

10. Special Pleading

Also called: double standard; ad hoc exemption

How it often shows up: Our later writing may judge the Bible; the Bible may not correct our later writing. Or: corruption explains every disagreeable verse, but agreeable verses remain reliable.

Why it fails: Rules applied to the other side are suspended for one’s own side without justification.

Clear thinking: Use one standard for textual history, dating, and manuscript evidence on all sides.

11. Circular Reasoning

Also called: circulus in probando

How it often shows up: The later book is true because it says the earlier books are corrupted; the earlier books are corrupted because the later book says so.

Why it fails: The claim supports itself with itself. No independent test is allowed.

Clear thinking: Ask for evidence outside the circle: manuscripts, early citations, internal coherence, and whether the corruption claim matches actual textual history.

12. Genetic Fallacy

Also called: fallacy of origins

How it often shows up: Paul was a Christian apostle; therefore his confession that Jesus is God does not count. Or: this source is Christian, so it is biased and false.

Why it fails: Origin does not decide truth. Eyewitnesses and early confessors are exactly whom you should hear—then test.

Clear thinking: Evaluate the claim by evidence and coherence, not by dismissing the speaker’s identity.

13. Red Herring / Whataboutism

Also called: ignoratio elenchi (missing the point); tu quoque when personal

How it often shows up: When asked whether Jesus is God according to the Bible, the reply shifts to Crusades, colonialism, church failures, or You believe X so what about Y.

Why it fails: Those topics may matter elsewhere. They do not answer who Jesus is in Scripture.

Clear thinking: Finish the identity question first. Moral failures of professing Christians do not rewrite John 20:28.

14. Appeal to False or Anachronistic Authority

Also called: argumentum ad verecundiam (misused); anachronism

How it often shows up: A late medieval forgery or a seventh-century rewrite is treated as the real Gospel against first-century witnesses.

Why it fails: Later is not earlier. A document written centuries after cannot outrank the earliest sources unless it has independent historical strength—which forgeries lack.

Clear thinking: Date the source. Ask who wrote it, when, and whether it can see the events. First-century witnesses beat late substitutes.

15. Non Sequitur

Also called: it does not follow; irrelevant conclusion

How it often shows up: Jesus got tired / slept / prayed / said the Father is greater; therefore he is not God.

Why it fails: Those facts follow from incarnation—true humanity—without canceling the acts and titles of deity in the same books. The leap skips the Bible’s actual claim.

Clear thinking: Ask whether the same Gospel that shows weakness also shows authority only God has. If both are present, the conclusion needs both, not one half.

16. Poisoning the Well

Also called: preemptive ad hominem

How it often shows up: Before hearing John or Paul, the listener is told: Your books are corrupted; your doctrine is association with God; you worship three gods.

Why it fails: The audience is trained to dismiss evidence before it is weighed.

Clear thinking: Hear the text first. Then judge. Pre-labeling is not inquiry.

Starter pair (the exact-words trap)

Objection: If Jesus would have said X, Y, and Z, then he would have said that he was God. He didn’t say my sentence; therefore he is not God.

Named errors: primarily Argument from Silence + Moving the Goalposts (often with a False Dichotomy: either my slogan, or not God).

That is not true as logic. God’s claim in Scripture is not required to arrive in your later wording. It is required to be weighed in the wording and deeds he actually gave.

Standing rules while using this list

  • Invite: Muslim readers are welcome to test objections here.
  • Do not equate: Later renamed figures are not the biblical Jesus by name-matching.
  • Do not soft-sell: A voice that denies Jesus is Lord and God is not treated as parallel truth (cf. the Bible’s own warnings about false christs and spirits that deny him).

Next entries to add

Living list—add as new objection shapes appear: loaded questions, appeal to majority in a region, motte-and-bailey on tawhid language, and chronological snobbery against the incarnation.